No Result
View All Result
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
MM News
اردو
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • National
  • Crime
  • Opinions
  • The Other Side
MM News
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • National
  • Crime
  • Opinions
  • The Other Side
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
MM News
اردو
  • Latest
  • National
  • Crime
  • Opinions
  • The Other Side-Pakistan
Home Opinion & Editorial Opinion

Parliamentary Budget Office

Salman Rasheed by Salman Rasheed
March 4, 2020
Reading Time: 4 mins read
Whenever a government in Pakistan presents a budget, there is scepticism as usual about the integrity of both the budget and macroeconomic figures presented by the government.
It is not a secret that past governments at all levels have “fudged” or manipulated budget numbers and economic statistics for both political purposes and attempts to hoodwink external economic institutions like the IMF. When we talk of good governance, this also includes fiscal governance or management of the public treasury by elected officials and public officeholders.
We need to improve the transparency, accuracy, and integrity of the budgeting process to make it a more meaningful exercise not just a jugglery of numbers that no one in the government or public has a clue what the economic impact is.
Adopting the best practices from other democratic countries, I strongly propose that we establish a Parliamentary Budget Office (PBO), which many countries have done:
  • USA: Congressional Budget Office created in 1974
  • United Kingdom: Office for Budget Responsibility created in 2010
  • Canada: Parliamentary Budget Office created in 2006
  • Australia: Parliamentary Budget Office created in 2012
  • Korea: National Assembly Budget Office established in 2003
  • Sweden: Fiscal Policy Council in Sweden established in 2007
The main objective of these economic institutions is providing independent and non-partisan analysis of the budget cycle, economic issues, and the financial implications of legislative proposals.
Given the public’s mistrust of the political system, the need for a PBO in Pakistan becomes ever more crucial to restoring faith in democracy.
The institutions named above can be a template for establishing a Pakistani equivalent, as all of them have earned a reputation of providing independent, non-political, professional, credible, and neutral analysis.
Mandate
  • An Act of Parliament should define the PBO’s legislative mandate and powers.
  • Parliamentary Budget Officer will head the Parliamentary Budget Office, who is an officer of both houses of parliament for a six-year term that can be extended for only one additional term of six years.
  • The PBO should provide independent analysis to Parliament on the budget, the estimates and other documents, as well as matters of particular significance relating to the nation’s finances or economy; and at the request of a committee or a parliamentarian, to estimate the financial cost of any proposal that relates to matters over which Parliament has jurisdiction. Certain committees can also request analyses of the nation’s finances or economy or the estimates.
  • In the months before a general election, the PBO has an added mandate of responding to requests from political parties or independent members of the National Assembly to estimate the financial cost of any election campaign proposal that the party or member is considering making.
  • The PBO’s would support Parliament by providing analysis, including analysis of macroeconomic and fiscal policy, to improve the quality of parliamentary debate and promote better budget transparency and accountability.
  • Parliamentary Budget Officer regularly testifies before a parliamentary committee.
  • All PBO reports are accessible to the public in both hard and soft copy.
Core Work
  • State of the Nation’s Finances: independent budget projections; estimates of the federal or provincial government’s structural budget balances, budget balance risk analysis, and along-term fiscal sustainability report.
  • Estimates Review: Expenditure analysis tracking the implementation of fiscal stimulus measures including impact assessment, reporting standards, flow of funds analysis, lapse forecasting and reports on the risk associated with the government’s spending restraint.
  • Economic Trends: analysis on a range of issues including country’s output gap, labour markets, and current economic indicators.
  • Financial Analysis: costing of policy measures.
The analysis and reports produced by the PBO will be a gauge of its effectiveness and integrity.  The parliamentarians and the public will be able to determine how independent and credible the PBO is.  Therefore, the head and staff of PBO through its working must ensure its independence, trust, and commitment to excellence.
The book ‘Why Nations Fail’ by Daron Acemoglu and James Robinson pointed out that one of three factors that hampers prosperity occurs when legislatures cannot hold the executive to account.
This is exactly the problem we face in Pakistan as our national and provincial assemblies have failed miserably in this duty.  The establishment of PBOs at both the center and provincial level will aid legislatures in the accountability of the executive, contribute to fiscal transparency, and improve governance.
ADVERTISEMENT
Tags: budgeteditorialmm newsOfficeparliamentaryParliamentary Budget Officepbo
ShareTweetSendShare
Previous Post

PPP offers complete support to Aurat March: Zardari

Next Post

PMA praises school closure to check coronavirus in Sindh

Related Stories

Jamil
Editorial

Beyond Handshakes: ECO’s Real Test Is Implementation

November 17, 2026
Jamil
Editorial

Pakistan Chairs ECO 2026-27: Trade, Energy and a Push for Peace

November 15, 2026
Jamil
Editorial

Trump’s Iran Gamble: Victory at 100 Percent, or a War Without End?

November 12, 2026
Editorial

Defeat of Trump and Future of the World

November 10, 2026
Next Post

PMA praises school closure to check coronavirus in Sindh

Latest

Bilawal Questions Pakistan’s System, But Who Will Question PPP’s 18-Year Rule in Sindh?

9 hours ago

Pakistani National or Iranian Agent? Man Behind Alleged Trump Assassination Plot Gets 27 Years

10 hours ago

Pakistani Group Acquires US Consul General’s Residence in Karachi for Rs6.92 Billion

11 hours ago

Gold Prices Crash to Lowest Level Since Sep 2025; Silver and Platinum Also Slide

11 hours ago

Middle East Tensions Fail to Stop Oil Price Decline as Brent Slips to $92.98

12 hours ago

Pakistan Forex Rates Today: Dollar, Pound, Euro and Riyal Prices Revealed

12 hours ago

Will Your Area Face a Power Cut on November 18? K-Electric Releases New Schedule

1 day ago

Bilawal Bhutto Drops a Political Bombshell, Says Pakistan Needs a Major Reset

1 day ago

Latest

Bilawal Questions Pakistan’s System, But Who Will Question PPP’s 18-Year Rule in Sindh?

9 hours ago

Pakistani National or Iranian Agent? Man Behind Alleged Trump Assassination Plot Gets 27 Years

10 hours ago

Pakistani Group Acquires US Consul General’s Residence in Karachi for Rs6.92 Billion

11 hours ago

Gold Prices Crash to Lowest Level Since Sep 2025; Silver and Platinum Also Slide

11 hours ago

Middle East Tensions Fail to Stop Oil Price Decline as Brent Slips to $92.98

12 hours ago

Pakistan Forex Rates Today: Dollar, Pound, Euro and Riyal Prices Revealed

12 hours ago

MM Digital (Pvt.) Ltd.

MM News is a subsidiary of the MM Group of Companies. It was established in 2019 with the aim of providing people of Pakistan access to unbiased information. Contact Details: 03200201537

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Advertise
  • MM News Urdu
  • The Other Side-Pakistan
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Top Pages

  • Latest News
  • Showbiz
  • OP-ED
  • Technology
No Result
View All Result
  • Latest News
  • National
  • Crime
  • Opinions

© Copyright 2024 MMNews - All Rights Reserved.