LAHORE: The Lahore High Court has held that a WhatsApp group’s creator or administrator cannot be made criminally liable simply by virtue of that status for objectionable content posted by other members of the group, unless there is specific evidence linking the administrator to the offence.
The ruling came from Justice Tariq Saleem Sheikh in a detailed order delivered while deciding a post-arrest bail application (Crl. Misc. No. 69895-B/2025) in a case registered under Pakistan’s blasphemy-related provisions of the Pakistan Penal Code and Section 11 of the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA), 2016.
“Vicarious criminal liability cannot be inferred merely from administrative status,” the Court observed, adding that a WhatsApp administrator typically has only the power to add or remove members and does not ordinarily review, moderate, or approve individual messages before they are posted.
The Court clarified, however, that this protection is not absolute.
An administrator may still face liability where the group was created for an unlawful purpose, where the administrator personally participates in circulating the objectionable content, facilitates or encourages its circulation, acts in concert with other members, or where a common intention, conspiracy, or abetment can be established from evidence gathered during investigation.
In reaching this conclusion, the Court examined a line of Indian precedents — including rulings of the Bombay, Kerala, and Delhi High Courts — which have similarly held that a group administrator cannot be equated with an “intermediary” or made vicariously responsible for the acts of group members in the absence of a specific statutory provision creating such liability.
The LHC noted these foreign judgments carry only persuasive value in Pakistani courts but found their underlying reasoning consistent with the principles of criminal liability under Pakistani law, particularly Section 109 of the Pakistan Penal Code, which requires abetment to rest on instigation, conspiracy, or intentional aid — not mere status.
The judgment sets out a broader framework distinguishing between different roles within a WhatsApp group: creators/administrators, ordinary members, and persons who actually upload, forward, or share offending content. Of these, the Court held that only the last category — the person actually responsible for originating or circulating the material — bears liability founded on their own conduct, rather than on any inferred responsibility for others’ actions.
Case-specific note: The ruling itself did not result in the petitioner’s release. The Court found that the prosecution’s case against him was not based merely on his membership or administrative role in the WhatsApp groups concerned, but on a forensic Technical Analysis Report that allegedly traced the offending content directly to his own seized cellphone. His bail application was accordingly dismissed.





![Vanya Beerkus and Angela Nikolau display a banner on top of the Empire State Building in Manhattan, New York City, on July 1 [Reuters]](https://mmnews.tv/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/couple-on-Empire-State-Building-75x75.webp)