KARACHI: The Sindh government has decided to request the Sindh High Court to constitute a judicial commission to oversee the investigation into the death of 25-year-old entrepreneur Mir Raza Ali. However, the victim’s family swiftly rejected the initiative, stating they never requested a commission and prefer letting the newly formed Joint Investigation Team (JIT) do its work.
Speaking on a current affairs television program, Sindh Home Minister Zia-ul-Hassan Lanjar announced that the provincial cabinet decided during a high-level meeting to formally write to the Chief Justice of the Sindh High Court. The proposed commission would be headed by High Court judges to ensure absolute transparency.
Key objectives outlined by the Home Minister include evaluating medical discrepancies, monitoring the probe and evaluating evidentiary shifts.
Lanjar said the judicial panel will review the conflicting medical findings—specifically comparing the flawed initial post-mortem report against the results from the court-ordered grave exhumation. He said High Court judges in the commission would supervise the ongoing investigation alongside the newly appointed JIT to guarantee an uncompromised process, adding that official opinions expressed by police chiefs or officers are not final determinations.
Family’s Legal Counsel Rejects Judicial Commission
In a swift pushback, human rights activist and family attorney Jibran Nasir rejected the provincial government’s announcement, clarifying that Mir Raza’s family neither sought nor consented to the creation of a judicial commission at this stage.
Nasir, in a statement issued late last night, stressed that forming a commission now would only cause procedural delays when momentum is already building.
He confirmed that the family is placing its trust in the newly constituted five-member JIT led by DIG Crime and Investigation Aamir Farooqi—which was formed after the old team was dissolved following allegations of police harassment and attempts to coerce a suicide confession.
Context of the Ongoing Murder Inquiry
The proposal for judicial oversight comes after weeks of intense public scrutiny following Mir Raza’s disappearance from his PECHS home on July 28 and the discovery of his body in Gulistan-e-Jauhar two days later.
Initial claims of suicide by police unravelled after a second autopsy revealed a rear-entry bullet trajectory, broken ribs, and pre-death physical trauma.
Following forensic proof of homicide, authorities upgraded the FIR to include Section 302 (Murder) of the Pakistan Penal Code, suspended negligent field officers, and transferred the case file to District Korangi for a fresh investigation.





