No Result
View All Result
Monday, July 28, 2025
MM News
اردو
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • National
  • Dramas
  • Showbiz
    File Photo

    Alizeh Shah claims she is receiving death threats from fellow actress

    (Image: cinebuster.in)

    Who is Ruchi Gujjar and what did she do?

    Chal Mera Putt 4

    Trailer released for Chal Mera Putt 4 featuring Pakistani stars

    Gen V

    Gen V returns: What shocking truths are unveiled in the season 2 trailer?

    Image: Dunya News

    Does Dua Zahra love Babar Azam? The actress shares what’s in her heart

    image: Screengrab

    What is controversial about Benazir Bhutto in Indian film Dhurandhar that angers Pakistanis?

  • Thought Box
  • Business
  • Opinions
  • Technology
  • The Other Side
MM News
  • Home
  • Latest News
  • National
  • Dramas
  • Showbiz
    File Photo

    Alizeh Shah claims she is receiving death threats from fellow actress

    (Image: cinebuster.in)

    Who is Ruchi Gujjar and what did she do?

    Chal Mera Putt 4

    Trailer released for Chal Mera Putt 4 featuring Pakistani stars

    Gen V

    Gen V returns: What shocking truths are unveiled in the season 2 trailer?

    Image: Dunya News

    Does Dua Zahra love Babar Azam? The actress shares what’s in her heart

    image: Screengrab

    What is controversial about Benazir Bhutto in Indian film Dhurandhar that angers Pakistanis?

  • Thought Box
  • Business
  • Opinions
  • Technology
  • The Other Side
No Result
View All Result
No Result
View All Result
MM News
اردو
  • Latest
  • Thought Box
  • Showbiz
  • Business & Stock
  • Opinions
  • Technology
  • The Other Side-Pakistan
Home Uncategorized

Parliament must decide on secret balloting in Senate elections: CJP

MM News Staff by MM News Staff
February 25, 2021
The Supreme Court of Pakistan issued its written verdict. Source: FILE.

The Supreme Court of Pakistan issued its written verdict. Source: FILE.

ISLAMABAD: Chief Justice of Pakistan (CJP) Gulzar Ahmed has said that the parliament is the forum that must decide the method of voting for Senate elections including the degree of secrecy as the court could not limit jurisdiction.

The Chief Justice made these remarks while heading a five-member larger bench that had taken up a presidential reference seeking open ballot for the upcoming Senate elections.

The Chief Justice asked the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) central leader Raza Rabbani to explain whether Senate elections were held under the Constitution or not. Raza Rabbani said that there were examples of voting in the lower house while the court was hearing the matter of the upper house of the parliament. The secret ballot was the voter’s own secret while a voter could share his secret with another voter and not with the state, he added.

He said that this was the intention of the Constitution so that there was no pressure on the voters. If the vote was made identifiable, it would not be just a voter’s secret, he added. He said that the Constitution protected the freedom of the voter and the identification of vote was tantamount to depriving a voter from his freedom.

He said that the question was whether the ballot was secret or not. The ballot was not secret but its secrecy commenced with the ballot paper coming in the hands of the voter. He said that the voter was also bound not to show vote and the secret ballot was protected in the Constitution. He said that voting also did bind state institutions and officials that they could not see the vote cast by a voter.

Justice Ijaz-ul-Ahsan, a member of the bench, asked the counsel that his argument was regarding the National Assembly elections. He said the voting for the National Assembly was free and free vote meant freedom of the voter. He said that there was no mention of free vote for Senate so it did not have to be secret. There was no reason to keep the vote secret with the idea of ‘proportional representation’, he added.

Raza Rabbani said that political parties had proportional representation in the National Assembly while the provinces had proportional representation in the Senate. If the court allowed an open ballot, the current election would be held under a temporary law and this provisional law already existed in the form of an ordinance, he added.

The Chief Justice responded that the court was not hearing the matter of ordinance. Rabbani said that he was not arguing about an ordinance but a constitutional point. According to the Constitution, elections of the Senate could not be held under a temporary law, he added.

Raza Rabbani said that the court only had to give an opinion in the presidential reference. Rabbani said the court only had to decide whether the Senate elections were held under the Constitution or not and next task was for the parliament.

He said that the parliament had to decide whether the vote in the Senate election would be open, identifiable or secret. The Parliament had to decide whether a constitutional amendment was required for Senate elections or a change in the law, he added.

He further said if the Supreme Court stated the Senate elections were not held under the Constitution then the presidential ordinance would come into force. He said if Parliament did not amend the Constitution or the law, then it would be deemed that the Senate elections were held under a temporary law.

Advocate Kamran Murtaza, the counsel for the Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam (JUI-F), said that the secrecy of the entire election process could not be finished for four or five votes. He said that a political question had been asked in the reference. The court should refer the matter to Parliament to answer the political question, he added.

Barrister Zaffarullah said that the Supreme Court should interpret the matter for the Senate elections, keeping in view the historical evolution. There were international resolutions to protect the secrecy of the vote, he added. The Chief Justice said that the court was not considering the question he was discussing.

The counsel for the Islamabad Bar Association said that the Supreme Court should decide whether the question raised in the presidential reference was worth answering or not. The counsel pleaded with the court to annul the reference as the question raised in the presidential reference was purely political.

Advocate Salahuddin, counsel for Sindh High Court Bar Association, said that his constitutional responsibility was to assist the judiciary. This was a serious political crisis and the court had to decide wisely, he added.

He said the current government had not apparently fulfilled its political responsibilities. He said that the reference on the Senate election was illegal. All parties except the ruling party were against it, he added.

The Chief Justice said that there were three options before the court. 1) Whether Article 226 applied to Senate elections or not? 2) Could there be proportional representation through a single transferable vote; and 3) Whether elections held under the Constitution were secret?.

He said that matters related to the secret ballot had been left for the Parliament. Salahuddin said that an amendment to this issue was already pending in Parliament. He said that the government also sent a reference and issued an ordinance.

The Chief Justice said that the court was not a parliament, nor it could limit its jurisdiction. Salahuddin said that the advice of the court had been sought through reference. The hearing of the case was adjourned till Thursday.

Tags: ballotChief JusticeELECTIONSenate
ShareTweetSendShare
Previous Post

Major terror plot foiled at Rawalpindi railway station

Next Post

Woman appeals for financial assistance to treat husband’s cancer

Related Stories

Screen grab
Uncategorized

Viral video sparks outrage as Karachi traffic police ‘fine’ cyclist

July 26, 2025
Imran Khan during court appearance: Fie photo
Uncategorized

Imran Khan moves SC after bail rejection in May 9 cases

July 26, 2025
File
Uncategorized

Buildings constructed on nullahs to be sealed in THIS Pakistan city

July 25, 2025
c
Top News

Safar moon 2025 not sighted across Pakistan

July 25, 2025
Uncategorized

Four young sisters drown in creek in Balochistan’s Loralai

July 25, 2025
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif (right) meets Dr Fouzia Siddiqui, sister of Dr Aafia Siddiqui, at the PM Office in Islamabad, on July 25, 2025. — APP
Top News

PM Sharif assures all possible support in Dr Aafia Siddiqui’s case

July 25, 2025
Online
Uncategorized

Son of rickshaw driver tops Punjab Matric exams in Arts group

July 25, 2025
File photo
Uncategorized

PTI leader Hammad Azhar decides to surrender before court

July 25, 2025
File photo
Uncategorized

PAF successfully completes rescue mission in GB after flash floods

July 25, 2025
Pic credit: DP
Uncategorized

Viral video: Revo overturns at Karachi’s Sea View

July 24, 2025
Next Post

Woman appeals for financial assistance to treat husband's cancer

Trending Stories

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman (File Photo)
Technology

Don’t share your deepest secrets with ChatGPT, warns Sam Altman

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025
File Photo
Daily Buzz

Alizeh Shah claims she is receiving death threats from fellow actress

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025
(Representational Image)
Crime

Two fake doctors arrested after performing surgery on woman in Bahawalnagar

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025
(Image: cinebuster.in)
Film & TV

Who is Ruchi Gujjar and what did she do?

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025
National

Karachi residents pay the highest price for flour in Pakistan

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025

Opinion

nadeem moulvi
From Sects to Sunnah
July 15, 2025
- Nadeem Moulvi
Munir-Ahmed
Portugal and Pakistan: Building a Bilateral Bridge in a Fractured World
June 29, 2025
- Munir Ahmed
munir ahmed oped
A Peace Prize for Betrayals: Rethinking Pakistan’s Strategic Alliances
June 28, 2025
- Munir Ahmed
No posts found
See all

Weather Updates

Rescue personnel evacuate villagers by boat from a flooded village following heavy rains in the Taunsa district of Punjab on July 16, 2025. — AFP
National

Thousands displaced, crops destroyed as floods wreak havoc in Punjab

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025

Floods have caused widespread devastation across several cities in Punjab, damaging crops and leaving...

File photo

KP issues travel advisory amid monsoon showers

July 26, 2025
Image: file photo

Weather updates for Islamabad, other parts of country

July 26, 2025
File Photo

Another monsoon spell to begin in Pakistan from July 28

July 25, 2025
See all

Prices

National

Karachi residents pay the highest price for flour in Pakistan

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025

Residents of Karachi are compelled to purchase the costliest flour in Pakistan, with a...

representative image

Gold prices in Pakistan today- Sunday 27 July 2026

July 27, 2025
representative image

Gold prices in Pakistan today- Saturday 26 July 2026

July 26, 2025
File Photo

Govt to deregulate electricity prices under new competitive energy market policy

July 25, 2025
See all

Transport News

Chakwal
Crime

Tragic bus crash in Chakwal: 6 dead, 24 injured near Dhok Sial

by MM News Staff
July 27, 2025

A bus fell into a ravine near Dhok Sial on the motorway in Chakwal,...

Charged Parking

Has the Sindh government put an end to parking fee extortion?

July 25, 2025

E-Taxi scheme launch date unveiled in Punjab

July 24, 2025
(File Photo)

Air Arabia Abu Dhabi expands operations in Pakistan with new Faisalabad, Multan flights

July 24, 2025
See all

MM Digital (Pvt.) Ltd.

MM News is a subsidiary of the MM Group of Companies. It was established in 2019 with the aim of providing people of Pakistan access to unbiased information. Contact Details: 03200201537

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Advertise
  • MM News Urdu
  • The Other Side-Pakistan
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy

Top Pages

  • Latest News
  • Showbiz
  • OP-ED
  • Technology
No Result
View All Result
  • Latest News
  • Showbiz
  • Thought Box
  • Business
  • Opinions
  • Technology

© Copyright 2024 MMNews - All Rights Reserved.